Case Study – Cavender’s
TMS integration and negotiations rein in shipping costs
14%
savings
on parcel spend annually
16%
savings
on LTL spend annually
Corralling shipping data to cut costs
Cavender’s was founded in 1965 by James and Pat Cavender in the small East Texas town of Pittsburg. For more than five decades, this family-owned western wear retailer has thrived by providing the best products at affordable prices with excellent customer service.
Cavender’s sells merchandise online and in more than 90 brick-and-mortar locations in the U.S. As with any online apparel retailer, parcel shipping plays a major role in maintaining a positive customer service experience. But when faced with parcel shipping capacity issues and rising inbound freight costs, they turned to AFS Logistics, an expert in the parcel and LTL freight markets with a proven data-driven approach.
“AFS has always been really proactive in bringing us new ideas and telling us what’s coming down the pike,” said Jim Thompson, Chief Financial Officer, Cavender’s family office.
Boosting parcel capacity and reducing spend
“AFS has always been really proactive in bringing us new ideas and telling us what’s coming down the pike,” said Jim Thompson, Chief Financial Officer, Cavender’s Family Office.
AFS helped Cavender’s identify another parcel carrier that was offering competitive pricing to gain new business. This offered the chance to not only address service and capacity issues, but significantly reduce overall parcel spend. Cavender’s gave AFS the green light to negotiate, but a problem emerged before negotiations even began. The carrier had a long standing policy of only negotiating contracts directly with shippers — not a third-party logistics provider.
But AFS didn’t give up. The team leveraged contacts in the same carrier’s LTL group — a 13-year relationship — to help initiate the parcel contract negotiation process. When the carrier realized that negotiating with AFS was the only way to win Cavender’s multi-million dollar annual parcel spend they made an exception, and negotiations commenced on a contract for 95% of Cavender’s parcel shipping business.
“AFS did a fantastic job of telling the carrier where they needed to be on cost and they had our full trust throughout the process,” said Thompson. “I told both our existing and new carriers that if you’re speaking to AFS, you’re speaking to Cavender’s.”
Improving freight visibility
Cavender’s also faced a significant challenge managing inbound freight costs. The company’s vendors routed merchandise and added less-than-truckload (LTL) shipping into the cost of goods as either a line item or as part of the total cost. To gain control of LTL spend, Cavender’s needed to establish set rates and implement technology that provided visibility into all inbound freight activities.
To set the necessary framework for Cavender’s to better control LTL inbound freight costs, AFS provided a transportation management system (TMS). The TMS manages 95% of Cavender’s LTL inbound freight through a vendor portal. AFS established carriers, set rates and trained approximately 400 Cavender’s vendors to use the portal. The TMS enables Cavender’s to manage inbound freight more accurately and effectively and provides enhanced visibility to all freight.
“We’d be bleeding millions of dollars in excess freight costs if we didn’t have AFS. They have the expertise, knowledge and systems that our business needs, and they do everything more efficiently than we could.”
Jim Thompson
Chief Financial Officer, Cavender’s Family Office
The results
The new contract negotiated by AFS and the new TMS:
- Reduced Cavender’s annual parcel spend by 14%
- Reduced LTL costs 16% annually by routing 95% of the company’s freight through the TMS
- Improved visibility across logistics, considerably reducing financial risks
“The solutions from AFS allow us to improve our margins and generate working capital — which is a huge improvement for us as we work to provide the best service possible to our customers,” said Thompson.
AFS continues to guide Cavender’s logistics operations, setting them up for success by keeping their customers satisfied with fair prices through skilled negotiations and data-driven decision making.