Case Study – Musco Olives
Unlocking efficiency and lowering costs with managed transportation services
>10%
savings
on total transportation spend in the first year
$150,000
recovered
in lost sales on a single shipment
100%
increase
in carrier mix
Rethinking outdated manual processes
The family-owned and operated Musco Family Olive Company (Musco) is the nation’s leading provider of table olives. Since 1942, the company has prided themselves on sourcing the highest quality olives from over 450 California farmers. Today, they are America’s number one olive brand and supply a significant portion to private labels equating to ownership of a majority of the U.S. market.
Efficient and cost-effective solutions for managing logistics operations are a fundamental requirement for Musco to meet demand and maintain the high level of quality to which they are committed. But, with most supply chain processes being handled manually — plus continually-rising shipping costs and other challenges in a post-pandemic market — it became more difficult for the company to scale their operations and coordinate shipments.
“As a family owned and operated business that’s been around for over 80 years, we had a lot of manual, outdated processes that just stuck around because it’s how we had always done it,” said Michael Lin, Senior Director of Supply Chain. “But with our volume, we knew we needed better efficiency to maintain service to our customers, mitigate the impact of rising transportation costs and reduce the margin of error that comes with the territory of basically managing all of our freight by hand.”
Automating with ERP-to-TMS integration
Musco didn’t have a coordinated system for tendering shipments, so the process consumed hundreds of valuable hours every week. The lack of coordination occasionally led to double, even triple brokering of loads. Musco was utilizing several brokers who would re-broker their freight to an asset-based carrier, leaving concerns about chain of custody.
To eliminate wasted time and excess cost across multiple modes, AFS implemented managed transportation for Musco, taking ownership of the entire life cycle of their shipments. AFS enabled automated order-to-shipment execution across Musco’s transportation workflows by connecting their enterprise resource planning (ERP) directly with SmartTMS, leveraging the API capabilities of SmartConnect, AFS’ flexible integration approach. All outbound freight for both sales and stock transfers are now electronically sent to AFS. Then, the most competitive rate is returned from a wider breadth of pre-vetted carriers and automatically loaded into the ERP for billing and tracking. By introducing this automation, AFS improved Musco’s workflows and reduced manual hours spent coordinating and managing shipments, scheduling delivery appointments and filing claims.
Additionally, the AFS managed transportation team supports Musco in quickly adjusting to market disruptions with mode optimization and full transparency to proactively address issues when they arise, maintaining the company’s high service standards.
Optimizing transportation network performance
Long-tenured brokers and carriers retained the Musco business year after year, resulting in inflated transportation costs. The company also had developed a regular broker mix so there was no impartial process that ensured the most cost-effective option was being used.
For ongoing support and optimization, AFS facilitates annual freight requests for proposals (RFPs) from start to finish, during which only asset-based providers are considered for Musco’s carrier network, eliminating double and triple-brokering scenarios. AFS also conducts network analyses to identify opportunities for movement or consolidation of warehouses. Quarterly business reviews are performed to track progress and performance and to pinpoint any excessive freight cost shipments.
In the next step of their logistics evolution, Musco handed over control of international shipments to AFS in order to reduce transit times, secure the chain of custody and help drive down higher than necessary volumes of safety stock. Scorecards are produced for transportation performance and are now produced for the company’s warehouse network as well to measure service and cost of each location. Additionally, 90% of the company’s track and trace for truckload and intermodal freight is done using AFS systems.
“AFS has been the differentiator that puts us where we need to be with rates and scaling operations to keep up with all the changes happening in the global and domestic supply chain.”
Michael Lin
Musco Senior Director of Supply Chain
Auditing to take control of shipping spend
Musco also lacked an effective track and trace system for visibility into the full life cycle of their shipments. Because they were not auditing their LTL, truckload or intermodal freight, they had no way of knowing if they were being inaccurately billed. And without visibility into the true cost of their freight and lack of data on load status, it became impossible for Musco to dispute claims such as on-time in-full (OTIF), leaving them vulnerable to overpaying on accessorial charges in customer deduction claims.
To help Musco gain control of inaccurate fees and surcharges, AFS executed an invoice audit process on all modes. Through a comprehensive review of every bill with machine-scale precision and accuracy, the company can recover spend from overcharges helping ensure they never pay more than they should, while simultaneously consolidating weekly billing into one invoice. By adding this practice to their standard operations, Musco now has a documented audit trail to assist in resolving any potential discrepancies.
The results
All of these services combine to make AFS a true one-stop shop for Musco Family Olive Company. By implementing more efficient processes and technology for Musco, AFS:
- Lowered the company’s total transportation spend by over 10% in the first year.
- Identified further opportunities in quarterly business reviews resulting in an additional $50,000 in annual savings.
- Saved the company over $150,000 in lost sales in one instance on a single shipment.
- Restructured roles and responsibilities within Musco to help them build capacity in other areas of their business.
- Increased the company’s carrier mix by 100%
“AFS has been the differentiator that puts us where we need to be with rates and scaling operations to keep up with all the changes happening in the global and domestic supply chain. Not only that, but the quality of the data they provide has revolutionized the efficiency of our warehousing network,” Lin said. “Our alliance vendors are considered part of the Musco family and AFS has truly become a part of our logistics team.”