Case Study – National Fashion Retailer

Reducing shipping costs through parcel audit

$800,000

saved

on parcel shipping over 12 months

$184,000

in overcharges avoided

in just one week

Picking up on problems in shipping invoices

A national fashion retailer with more than 1,000 brick-and-mortar stores and an e-commerce presence sells apparel, shoes and accessories for women and children. Headquartered on the East Coast, the retailer maintains a multi-level warehouse and ships merchandise to their stores throughout the U.S., Puerto Rico and U.S. Virgin Islands. As orders come in, the merchandise is packed at the warehouse and immediately scanned, sorted and placed directly into trucks for delivery. More than 90% of the retailer’s $24 million in annual parcel shipping spend is through a single national carrier.

At one point, when the carrier eliminated discounts for some individual accounts, they inadvertently started charging list rates for thousands of the retailer’s shipments. Another time, when the retailer opened a new store, shipments to that store were not routinely associated with their contracted discounts. And, at various times, shipping charges were also misapplied, leading to an even greater need for the retailer to keep a close eye on their parcel shipping invoices.

Plucking out overcharges through detailed parcel audits

For the last decade, the retailer has relied on AFS parcel auditing to identify and track discrepancies in their parcel shipping invoices and recover eligible refunds. When billing errors occur, AFS finds the discrepancy, communicates the amount to the carrier and seeks confirmation from the carrier when the refund is approved.

Every week, AFS provides the retailer with reports that contain package-level detail and audit findings. The retailer then scrutinizes these reports and provides the information to their executive committee for review.

“AFS has made it easy to identify what the report is conveying, and our executives can manage their way through them. We didn’t want to drown them with data,” said the supply chain logistics director.

Every year, the retailer tasks AFS with analyzing their total parcel spend to verify that their contracted 3.5% rate cap isn’t exceeded. Through the audit process, AFS has identified instances where the rate cap was surpassed and worked with the carrier to have the rates adjusted to 3.5% or less.

“No matter what home-grown system you’ve built, AFS is more equipped and a thousand times better. Your accounts payable and IT groups aren’t the answer. AFS auditors are the professionals.”

Director of Supply Chain Logistics

National Fashion Retailer

The results

By engaging AFS parcel shipping experts to audit their invoices, the retailer:

  • Managed to save nearly $800,000 on its parcel spend over a 12-month period
  • Capitalized on $184,000 in savings AFS found in the course of just one week

If not for AFS, the retailer would have to build in-house capacity to perform parcel audits. Outsourcing their parcel audit to AFS made the most sense, from both an internal resources and industry expertise perspective.

Explore more real-world shipping wins

  • Two people riding horses while wearing Cavender’s western wear
    CASE STUDY

    Cavender’s

    This western wear retailer’s shipping spend increased exponentially during the COVID-19 pandemic. AFS renegotiated the company’s parcel carrier contract, consolidated LTL carriers and provided a best-in-class TMS — saving 14% on parcel spend and 16% on LTL spend annually.

  • A Rexel technician working on electrical equipment
    CASE STUDY

    Rexel

    Global electrical distributor, Rexel USA, saved over $1 million in total parcel spend after working with AFS for one year to establish new technology and processes, including a custom software solution, GRI negotiations and carrier consolidation.

  • Musco Family Olive Company
    CASE STUDY

    Musco Family Olive Company

    By implementing more efficient processes and technology, AFS saved the nation’s leading provider of table olives more than 10% on their total transportation spend in the first year.